Host Opinions
18th
|
popdot07
|
Pop was voted out because he was a nuisance to the other castaways. He thought he was in control of his tribe when he clearly was the pawn. When Cookie decided that he needed to go, he went. I feel bad for him though. His dog died the day he was voted out.
|
17th
|
CrazyBrittnxy
|
Whether Brittney knew it or not, she was at the mercy of Cookie. Brittney's downfall was wanting Kyle out. Brittney though that Kyle should be the first boot, and Cookie didn't like that. She sent Brittney home as soon as possible.
|
16th
|
NancyStrikesAgain
|
Nancy was a dictator. She organized an alliance and gave them orders. I actually loved watching her play. She reminded me so much of Heather from Total Drama Island when she bossed Jakk, Dave, and Kronnny around like Lindsay and Beth. She was entertaining to say the least.
|
15th
|
Valkryiah
|
Valk quit because she gave up Roblox. I respect her decision, but I just wished she stuck around longer. She was considered a challenge threat, and had a lot of potential. I expected her to at least make the merge. I was disappointed with her decision, but it is what it is.
|
14th
|
Alt_nat
|
Nat surprised me in a good way. She wasn't a part of the original cast. She was a backup. Whenever she came to a session, she brought a smile to my face with her cheeriness and positivity. She reminded me of Sam from BB20. Whenever she tried something strategic, it blew up in her face. She was voted out for trying to play the game. She was truly robbed.
|
13th
|
kyle5470
|
Kyle deserved to make it further than she did. She played an amazing game in season 2, and was unable to do that again for two reasons. First of all, Cookie the strategic evil mastermind controlled all of Lalomanu. Kyle had no chance at manipulating people after Cookie got to them. Secondly, there was a ton of pressure on her. She was one of the only two vets in a season filled with newbies. She had a reputation of being a mastermind, so everyone assumed she would control the season. When she was voted out, I thought for sure that she would win her redemption island duel. She deserved to make it further.
|
12th
|
iiSuperDave
|
Dave actually was a pretty decent player for the first half of the game. He stuck with his allies on Salamumu, staying in the majority for the pre-merge. Once the merge happened, he went insane. He flipped out after finding out about Kronnny's alliance with a few of the members of Lalomanu. He started exposing everyone's games. Even after being sent to redemption island, he continued to freak out. He was eventually expelled from the game. He reminded me of Brandon Hantz, the guy who went insane on Survivor: Caramoan and dumped all the rice into the fire.
|
11th
|
AviationMaster345
|
Aviation was expelled for inactivity. He always said how he was a huge fan of Survivor, and it was unfortunate that he wasn't able to come to a lot of the sessions. If he didn't get expelled, he would've gotten voted out sooner or later. When Dave left, he sealed the fate of all the Salamumu men. (Aviation, Jakk, and Kris) They were outnumbered and voted out by Cookie and her minions.
|
10th
|
zingbotz
|
Zing was expelled for inactivity. She annoyed a lot of the castaways with her complaining. The other castaways probably would've taken her to the end since she would've been easy to beat. Her application was better than everyone else's, and it's a shame that she didn't really bring much gameplay to the table.
|
9th
|
Jakkariah
|
I knew that Jakk would be voted out eventually, due to Cookie having the numbers. I loved watching Jakk trying to flip to be with the Lalomanu alliance. Similar to Nat, Jakk put a smile on my face every session. He was a well rounded player who always tried to think a step ahead of his competition.
|
8th
|
Kronnny
|
Like Jakk, he was screwed once Dave and Aviation left. There was nothing he could do except win redemption. He was actually really close to coming back, but fell just short. He deserved a chance to reenter and prove himself, but that never happened. Overall, he was a pretty social player.
|
7th
|
GreenBrandonsmash
|
I expected a lot more from Green. In other longterms, He's been called great, and even a legend. I really just didn't see any of that from him this season. From my point of view, he was a coaster who did whatever his allies told him to do. He showed loyalty, but he didn't show strategy.
|
6th
|
vichaya
|
Vich was labeled the competition beast of the season by her fellow castaways, and I just don't see that. Kyle won most of Lalomanu's competitions for them, and Vich only won 1 individual immunity. (Two if you count the one where she got it when Lalomanu went to tribal.) She never won any of her redemption duels. She came in second in all of them that she competed in, barely surviving numerous times. Other than voting with the majority most of the time, she didn't really do much.
|
5th
|
drewdabomb2603
|
Drew was actually really interesting to watch. Throughout most of the season, I just saw him as Cookie's sheep, but he changed in the end. He realized that Cookie was the biggest threat, and tried to take her out. No one listened to him though, because Cookie was too sneaky. He was a constant target. When people didn't know who to vote for, they often voted either Drew or Cookie. Drew received votes at every merge tribal he was at except one.
|
4th
|
IceyRoboGamez
|
Icey didn't really stand out to me this season. I thought he would be the first boot for sure. His whole tribe was targeting him for leaking an alliance to the other tribe, but Cookie stepped in and saved him. He was a pretty average player. He was so close to being voted out at the final 6. He was being targeted so much and he didn't even realize it. Immunity saved him. I feel like he would've had a good chance to win if Cookie and Cleo weren't a part of the season. He fought hard and ended up falling just short of the final 3.
|
3rd
|
McPiggy04
|
Kenna was a little boring to watch, but she played a huge role in the season. She was almost expelled for missing sessions before the merge, but she became active and made alliances. (Technically, people approached her and not the other way around.) She became close to Cookie and Cleo in particular. This power trio of women bulldozed its way to the end, crushing all the men. (And Vich.) They were split up when she had to choose the winner between her two closest allies. I thought it was really interesting how she actually tried to vote out Cleo at the final 4.
|
2nd
|
CleopatraDeTwilight
|
Cleo actually did really good, considering she was targeted early for being a vet. When she was sent to redemption island, I thought she would lose for sure. She surprised me, winning duel after duel and returning to the game. When she came back, everyone was planning on voting her out again, but Cookie saved her by switching the target over to Dave and the Salamumu men. Cleo played a pretty mediocre game during the merge. She stuck with Cookie and made some of the same moves as her. Cookie wanted her out for being a vet, but she never got the opportunity to put that plan into action. When Cleo got to the final tribal council, she made an amazing speech. This caused a lot of people to switch their votes to her. She almost became the first two time winner, which isn't a small feat. I was amazed at how well she did this season, considering she came into the season with a target on her back for being one of the only two vets.
|
1st
|
cookiez636486
|
Cookie was amazing this season! She was my winner pick from the beginning. One by one, each person who she wanted gone was sent home. She managed to sneak past all her competition. She was controlling everyone, but the only person who knew she was a threat was Drew. She kept the numbers in the merge by turning her enemies against each other. The first time she was ever in any real danger was in the final 5 when Kenna almost flipped on her and Cleo. Even then, she managed to make Cleo a bigger target than herself. I thought for sure that Cleo was going to win over Cookie because of the amazing speech she gave, but I was surprised. Cookie guilt tripped Kenna into giving her the win. This was amazing gameplay by her. She had better confessionals than anyone else this season. Her ability to bond with others over immature fart jokes was unlike anything I've ever seen before. Everyone ended up loving her. She filled the Rodent Long Terms legacy and became the female mastermind of season 4.
|