Episode 1: It's Only A Matter of Time
2 returning castaways, Cleo and Kyle, joined 16 all new players. It was revealed that redemption island was in play this season! Valk from Salamumu competed against Zing from Lalomanu in an opening reward challenge. Valk won, giving Salamumu an advantage in the immunity challenge. The immunity challenge was a difficult obby. Each tribe had to get 3 members to the end, but due to the advantage that Valk won, Salamumu only had to get two to the end. Drew and Kyle completed it for Lalomanu. Valk completed it for Salamumu. With each tribe needing just one more person to the end to win, Kronnny made it to the end, sending Lalomanu to tribal council. Zing sat in the Questionnaire Chair. By a vote of 5-3, Brittney was the first person voted out of Survivor 4: Redemption Island. Cookie received the other 3 votes.
Episode 2: My Dinner Is Fried Rat On A Stick
The tribes competed in a hurdle immunity challenge. Zing, being on mobile, was left behind by her tribe. Lalomanu lost the challenge. Cookie sat in the Questionnaire Chair. By a vote of 5-2 Pop was voted out. Zing got the other 2 votes. Pop and Brittney competed in a block pushing redemption duel. Brittney beat Pop. The score was 9 to 4. Lalomanu pulled out their first comp win. They defeated Salamumu in a maze reward challenge. Lalomanu received an advantage in the reward challenge. With the reward, Lalomanu won by a long shot. (Slaps knee at own joke. The challenge was throwing balls into tubes. Shooting long. Hahahahaha. Cries.) Salamumu was dead set on voting out Cleo, the only returning player on their tribe. By a vote of 6-2, Cleo was sent to redemption island. The other two votes were for Nancy. Cleo and Brittany competed in a puzzle redemption duel. Cleo beat Brittany. The score was 256 to 176.
Episode 3: The Slaves Are Escaping!
Lalomanu won their second immunity challenge in a row. They beat Salamumu in the same puzzle Brittany and Cleo did in redemption. The score was 252 to 240. At tribal, Nancy sat in the Questionnaire Chair. She was then voted out and sent to Redemption Island. The vote was 3-1-1-1-1. Valk, Jakk, Dave, and Piggy each got a vote. Cleo automatically won the duel because Nancy didn't show up.
Episode 4: Storm Warning - Blindside Ahead
Valk chose to quit the game, leaving the tribes uneven. In an immunity challenge all about teamwork, Lalomanu pulled out yet another win, sending Salamumu to tribal council for the third time in a row. Nat sat in the Questionnaire Chair. By a vote of 4-1-1, Nat was voted out. Dave and Kronnny each received a vote. Cleo beat Nat in an obby duel. For the next immunity challenge, it was revealed that the best performing member of the losing tribe would win immunity along with the winning tribe. (They would still go to tribal and vote.) 4 people from each tribe were selected to participate. Kronnny won the challenge for Salamumu, ending Lalomanu's winning streak. Vich received individual immunity. At tribal, Kyle was blindsided in a 3-2-1 vote. Cookie received 2 votes while Zing received 1. Cleo and Kyle competed in an epic duel to return to the game. Cleo beat Kyle, winning another duel and returning to the game. The tribes merged.
Episode 5: You Are Nothing To Me
Kris won the log rolling reward challenge, giving him an advantage in the immunity challenge. He chose to share it with Jakk. In the "Get a Grip" immunity challenge, many competitors fell early. Only Green, Jakk, and Kris were left after the first five rounds. Green and Kris then fell, giving Jakk immunity. At tribal council, Kris sat in the Questionnaire Chair. By a vote of 4-2-1-1-1, Dave was voted out. Cookie received 2 votes while Drew, Cleo, and Kris each received one. Dave was banned for being extremely rude and exposing everyone's games with screenshots.
Episode 6: Why Do The Worst Things Happen To The Best People?
To start off the craziest session yet, Aviation and Zing were expelled for inactivity, leaving 9 players left in the game and no one on redemption island. The remaining castaways competed in a maze immunity challenge. Vich won, securing her spot in the final 8. At tribal council, Icey sat in the Questionnaire Chair. By a vote of 5-2-1, Kris was sent to redemption island. Drew received 2 votes while Green got 1. Drew and Cookie then won a sit trip spin reward challenge, automatically moving onto round 2 of the immunity challenge. Cleo and Jakk soon joined Drew and Cookie on round 2 by winning round 1. Cookie won immunity, putting herself into the final 7. Cookie sat in the Questionnaire Chair. By a close vote of 4-3-1, Jakk was sent to redemption island. Vich received 3 votes and Cleo received 1. Vich won the head hoppers reward challenge. Green beat Vich in a close battle for immunity. At tribal council, Cleo sat in the Questionnaire Chair. By a vote of 3-2-1-1, Vich was sent to redemption island. Drew received 2 votes while Cookie and Icey each received one. Kris, Jakk, and Vich competed in a block pushing redemption duel. Kris won with a monumental score of 11. It was close between Jakk and Vich, but Jakk was sent to the jury by a 3-2 score.
Episode 7: Another Day, Another Betrayal
Cleo won the "Touchy Subjects" immunity challenge. At tribal council, Icey sat in the Questionnaire Chair. There was a 3-1 vote to send Green to redemption island. Drew received one vote. Vich, Kris, and Green competed in a duel that tested their strategic skills. Green survived with a score of 89. Vich survived with a score of 79. Kris was eliminated with a score of 74. Icey won by a long shot in the head hopping/ball pushing immunity challenge. No one sat in the Questionnaire Chair. By a close vote of 3-2, Drew became the last castaway of the season to go to redemption island. Drew, Vich, and Green competed in an obby competition. Green lost and was eliminated. Drew and Vich had tied. They competed in a tiebreaker competition. Drew won and returned to the game.
Episode 8: Farting To The Win
The final 5 competed in a reward challenge with a twist. They had the option of sitting out. If only one person sat out, they would receive immunity. Cookie and Icey sat out, giving Cleo an advantage in the immunity challenge. Cleo put that advantage to good use, winning the challenge. Icey sat in the Questionnaire Chair. There was a tie vote of 2-2-1. Drew and Cookie recurved 2 votes while Icey received one. In the revote, Drew received 2 votes while Cookie received 1. With the final tribal council in sight, the final 4 competed in a jump/endurance competition. Icey dropped out first. Piggy soon followed him. Cookie then beat Cleo, earning herself a spot at the final tribal council. Cookie sat in the Questionnaire Chair. There was a tie vote of 2–2 between Cleo and Icey. They competed in a fire making challenge, and Cleo survived, sending Icey to the jury. Cleo, Cookie, and Kenna faced the jury. It turned out to be a 3-3 tie between Cleo and Cookie. Kenna then became the seventh member of the jury and chose Cookie to win over Cleo. Cookie won host's favorite player for her amazing gameplay.