Episode 1: Reverse The Curse
20 one time players returned for a second chance. They were divided into 2 tribes of 10. Naviti and Malolo soon found out that Ghost Island would be in play. It was revealed that both tribes were going to vote someone out, and that one person would win immunity from each tribe. Everyone competed in a truss-climbing immunity challenge. Exploit won immunity for Naviti while Malevolent won immunity for Malolo. Malevolent had the better time so she chose Naviti to go to tribal first. At Naviti's tribal council, Green was sent home in an 8-1-1 vote, with Nate and Jalen each receiving a vote. At Malolo's tribal council, Albert was sent home in a 7-1-1-1 vote, with Squid, Jamie, and Josh each receiving a vote.
Episode 2: I'm Risking It
Naviti and Malolo competed in the "Knight Moves" immunity challenge. Malolo ran out of moves first, giving Naviti the win. Naviti couldn't decide on who to send to Ghost Island from Malolo so Malevolent was randomly selected. At Ghost Island, Malevolent could play a game. There were 3 urns. Only one had an advantage inside. If she chose to play and picked one of the wrong urns, she would lose her vote. She chose to play and picked urn 3. Malevolent received an immunity idol from urn 3. Malevolent then returned to camp. At Malolo's tribal council, Squid was sent home in a 5-3-1 vote, with Cookie receiving 3 votes and Spartan receiving 1.
Episode 3: Give Me A Chance
Naviti and Malolo competed in the "Gun Fight" immunity challenge. Both tribes died at the same time. In the tiebreaker, Malolo won immunity. They couldn't decide on who to send to Ghost Island so Nate was randomly selected. At Ghost Island, Nate chose not to smash an urn. At Naviti's tribal council, Exploit was sent home in a 5-3-1 vote, with Emilee getting 3 votes and Nate getting 1.
Episode 4: You're Gonna Have To Drag Me
The tribes competed in "Kicking and Screaming". Malolo earned the first point. Naviti earned a point. Malolo then earned their second and third points, winning immunity. Edvin was randomly selected to Ghost Island. He picked an urn with nothing in it and lost his vote. At Naviti's tribal council, Mina was sent home in a unanimous 6-1 vote.
Episode 5: You're Crossing The Line
The final 15 swapped tribes. They swapped to 2 tribes of 7 with one person going to Ghost Island. Edvin was randomly selected to go to Ghost Island. He picked an urn with nothing in it and lost his vote. Naviti and Malolo competed in a difficult block pushing immunity challenge. Isaac was the only one able to complete it, winning immunity for Naviti. At Malolo's tribal council, Malevolent played an idol for himself, negating 1 vote. By a vote of 5-1, Jalen was sent home. Emilee received a vote.
Episode 6: Pulling A Jessica
The tribes competed in "Human Jousting". Malolo won all three rounds, winning immunity. Isaac was randomly sent to Ghost Island. He received an idol from urn 1. At tribal council, a 4-3 vote sent Spartan packing over Isaac.
Episode 7: I'll Make Up A Good Lie
Naviti and Malolo competed in a roll rolling challenge. In a 5-2 match, Malolo won immunity. Random was randomly selected to go to Ghost Island. At Ghost Island, she received an idol from urn 3. At Naviti's tribal council, Isaac played his idol for himself, negating no votes. Random was blindsided with an idol in her pocket by a 4-2 vote, with Jamie getting the 2 votes.
Episode 8: On The Bottom
The tribes merged. The final 12 competed in a hurdles immunity challenge. Alex and Cookie tied, but Alex won by a second in the tiebreaker. Alex sent Josh to Ghost Island. Josh chose not to smash an urn. At tribal council, Emilee was voted out in an 8-2-1 vote, with Bloop receiving 2 votes and Malevolent receiving 1.
Episode 9: I Have Options
The castaways competed in the Arthur timer challenge. Cookie won immunity, getting up to round 16. He sent himself to Ghost Island where he picked the wrong urn and lost his vote. At tribal council, a 5-3-2 vote sent Alex to the jury, with Edvin getting 3 votes and Isaac getting 2.
Episode 10: The Double Blindside
The final 10 was split into 2 groups of 5, with Bloop, Nate, Mya, Malevolent, and Jamie being placed on Naviti and Isaac, Josh, Jeremiah, Cookie, and Edvin being placed on Malolo. Mya and Josh won immunity, but Mya got the overall best time. She chose to send herself to Ghost Island, where she picked the wrong urn, losing her vote. At Malolo's tribal council, Isaac was sent home in a 3-2 vote against Edvin. At Naviti's tribal council, Malevolent was sent home in a 3-1 vote against Jamie. The final 8 remerged.
Episode 11: Returning The Favor
Cookie won the pole jumping immunity challenge in a blowout against everyone else. He sent himself to Ghost Island where he received an idol from urn 1. A tribal council, a 4-3-1 vote sent Jeremiah to the jury, with Edvin receiving 3 votes and Mya receiving 1.
Episode 12: The Wicked Witch Is Dead
The final 7 competed in Touchy Subjects, revealing a lot about the tribe. Jamie won immunity and sent himself to Ghost Island. Jamie picked the wrong urn and lost his vote. By a vote of 4-2, Mya was sent packing.
Episode 13: On The Outs
The remaining castaways competed in "Get A Grip". Jamie won immunity and once again sent himself to Ghost Island. He once again picked the wrong urn and lost his vote. At tribal council, Cookie played his idol on himself, negating no votes. Bloop was sent to the jury in a 4-1 vote, with Edvin getting Bloop's vote.
Episode 14: I'm Not Letting Fate Decide
The final 5 competed in a head-hopping ball-pushing immunity challenge. Cookie was the last one standing, winning immunity. He sent himself to Ghost Island where he picked the wrong urn, losing his vote. There was a 2-2 tie between Edvin and Jamie at tribal council. On the revote, both Nate and Josh voted Edvin, sending him packing.
Episode 15: I Messed Up
The final 4 competed in their final immunity challenge, which involved cliff jumping. Cookie won immunity, earning a spot in the final 3. Josh became the last member of the jury in a unanimous 3-1 vote. At the final tribal, Mya turned the jury against Nate and Jamie. Mya, Jeremiah, Malevolent, Emilee, Alex, and Bloop then relentlessly attacked Nate and Jamie until the jury awarded Cookie the win in a 4-3-2 vote, with Jamie getting 3 votes and Nate getting 2. Nate won host's favorite player.